What Is a Good Keyword Difficulty Score for a New Website?
Why a new site needs lower readings than established rivals, how to read the results page behind each score and how to find your own ceiling in Search Console.
- Monthly searches
- How hard it is to rank
- Related searches

A good keyword difficulty score for a new website is a reading near the bottom of your chosen tool's scale, attached to a phrase your customers actually search, on a results page where ordinary businesses already appear. Tools calculate scores differently, so compare phrases within one tool and raise your sights as your site earns links.
- Google names 5 broad kinds of ranking signal and counts links from prominent websites as a sign of quality, which a new domain does not yet have (Google on how results are ranked).
- Search Console reports the topmost position per query and averages them, so queries at positions 2 and 3 show 2.5 (Search Console Help on performance data).
- Local map results depend on 3 factors, relevance, distance and prominence, which most difficulty scores do not measure (Google Business Profile Help on local ranking).
Why does a new website need lower scores than established rivals?
A new website has few links, few indexed pages and no track record, so a phrase an older rival finds easy can stay out of reach for months.
Keyword difficulty scores are built mainly from the strength of the pages already ranking for a phrase: how many other websites link to them and how established those websites are. A high reading means the first page is held by sites with long histories; a low one means the pages there are younger or less linked. None of this measures how good your own page would be, only how strong the pages you would have to pass already are. How the scores are built and read in general belongs to the wider guide on keyword difficulty; a new site mainly needs to know which readings to aim for.
A site that went live this year sits at the very bottom of that measure, so the same reading means something different for you than for a business online for ten years. Google's own description of ranking treats links from prominent websites as one sign of trust, and a young domain has almost none. A physiotherapist in Kisumu or a mechanic in Bristol starting from scratch therefore needs to aim lower than the established clinic or garage across town. That is not a judgement on the quality of their pages, only on what Google can see about the site so far.
The practical way to see where you stand is to test real phrases rather than guess. Write down six or seven things a customer might type, such as "sports massage Kisumu", "physiotherapy for knee pain" and "physio home visits Kisumu", and run them through our keyword difficulty checker for your country. Look at the spread rather than any single figure. Most lists contain a few phrases near the bottom of the scale, a middle group and one or two plainly out of reach, and that spread is where your planning begins.
What makes a difficulty score good for a new site's keywords?
A good reading for a new site sits near the bottom of your own list and belongs to a phrase with real demand and clear buying intent.
Treat the number as a comparison between phrases rather than a pass mark, because each tool calculates it differently and the same phrase can carry quite different readings in two tools. Within one tool, though, the order is useful: a phrase with a lower reading is usually the easier of the two. Start with the lowest band of the scale, where the tool is telling you the first page is held by modest pages. Middle readings are not forbidden, but they belong to a second wave, best attempted once your first pages have started to appear.
A low reading only counts as good if the phrase is worth having. Some phrases are easy because almost nobody searches them, or because the people who do want something you do not sell. A mobile mechanic in Bristol might find that "how to change brake pads yourself" has a gentle reading, yet the people typing it want to do the job at home. A phrase with modest demand and clear intent, such as "mobile brake pad replacement Bristol", is worth far more to a new site than a popular phrase that attracts the wrong visitors.
For a new website, then, good means three things at once. It is low enough to win, relevant enough to bring enquiries and searched often enough to matter. Drop any phrase that fails one of those tests, however attractive its reading looks.
How do you check what sits behind a score?
Search the phrase in a private browser window and study the first page: other businesses and half answers mean room for you, national brands everywhere mean wait.
The score is a summary, so look at what it summarises. If you see other businesses, local directory listings, forum threads or pages that only half answer the question, the phrase is within reach even if its reading is not the lowest on your list. If national chains, government websites, large publishers and marketplaces fill every position, a newcomer will struggle whatever the number says. Reading the page this way saves you writing pages nobody will see.
A florist in Cape Town who searches "wedding flowers" is likely to meet large wedding portals and national delivery companies. A search for "protea bridal bouquet Stellenbosch" may turn up a mix of small florists and photographers' blogs. That second kind of results page is one a new site can join, and the difference is often clearer on the page than in the score. Note the format of the results too, because a phrase answered entirely by guides is a poor target for a sales page.
How do you find the ceiling your own site can handle?
Measure it from your own rankings: the highest reading among phrases where you already appear on the first or second page is a fair estimate of your current ceiling.
Once your site has been live for a couple of months and Google has indexed its main pages, open Google Search Console and go to the Performance report. Switch on average position, look through the queries and note the phrases where your pages already appear near the top. Search Console takes the topmost position your site holds for each query, so the figure reflects your best page for that search. Run those phrases through the same tool you used before and write down their readings.
Aim most new pages at phrases at or a little below that ceiling, and try one or two slightly above it as experiments. When the experiments start to appear on the first page, your ceiling has moved and you can raise your sights. The Bristol mechanic might find after three months that he ranks well for brake and clutch phrases in two nearby districts, all with low readings. That tells him to keep writing pages of that kind and to hold back on broad phrases such as "car servicing Bristol" until the site has more behind it.
If your site is so new that Search Console has almost nothing to show, start without that evidence. Take the lowest readings on your list, check that each passes the relevance test, and build a page for the strongest three or four. Google's SEO Starter Guide says some changes show within hours while others take several months, so give them a few weeks, watch the Performance report and treat the first phrases that appear as your benchmark.
What can you do when every phrase looks hard?
Add detail until each phrase describes a narrower need, because readings usually fall as phrases become more specific.
The usual cause of a daunting list is short, general phrases, which are exactly the ones large websites compete for. Add the problem, the material, the type of customer, the neighbourhood or the occasion. A physiotherapist in Kisumu who finds "physiotherapy" crowded can look at "physiotherapy after a knee operation Kisumu" or "physio for back pain from long drives". Each describes a real patient and is far more likely to be won by a clinic that writes about it properly.
Related searches and questions are the richest source of these narrower phrases. The checker lists searches people type around your original phrase, and Google shows its own at the foot of the results page. Questions are often the easiest of all, because many large sites do not answer them in plain terms. A page explaining how many sessions a sprained ankle usually needs, written by someone who treats them every week, has a fair chance against general health publishers.
Location helps in a different way. Many local searches show a map above the ordinary results, and Google ranks those places on relevance, distance and prominence through your Business Profile, which most difficulty scores ignore. A phrase with a high reading can still bring customers through the map while your website builds strength, so complete your profile early.
How do you turn scores into a plan for the first three months?
Spend month one on core service pages, month two on question pages, and month three on measuring your first ceiling in Search Console.
In the first month, build or improve the pages for your core services, each aimed at the lowest reading phrase that describes that service with your town or area. In the second month, add two or three pages that answer the questions you gathered, again choosing the gentlest readings first. In the third month, open the Performance report, see which phrases have started to appear and work out your first ceiling. That rhythm keeps you writing for phrases you can win while you gather evidence.
Keep simple records in a spreadsheet or notebook. For each phrase, note the date you checked it, its monthly searches, its reading, the page you wrote and where it ranks a month later. After a season you will have evidence no general article can give you, and you will notice when a reading shifts as competitors arrive or fall away. The other AI SEO tools from AI Web Maker can then check whether those pages are set up well enough to rank for the phrases you chose.
Questions new website owners ask
Is there one keyword difficulty number every new site should stay under?
No. Each tool uses its own formula, so a safe reading in one tool may look different in another. Use the lowest band of your chosen tool as a starting point, then replace that rule with your own ceiling once Search Console has data.
How long before a new site can target harder keywords?
It depends on how quickly the site earns links and gets pages indexed, not on a fixed date. Measure your ceiling every few months; when experiments slightly above it start ranking, move up a step.
Should a new site ignore high difficulty keywords completely?
Not if they sit at the heart of your business. Write one strong page for such a phrase and let it mature, while easier pages bring the first visitors. Just do not make it the only page you rely on.
Do difficulty scores apply to Google Maps results?
Mostly not. Map results depend on your Business Profile's relevance, distance and prominence, while most difficulty scores describe the ordinary results. A local business can win map visits on phrases its website cannot yet rank for.
Start low and climb with evidence
A good starting score is the lowest reading on your list that still brings the right customers, and the climb from there should follow your own results.
Pick one tool and stay with it, so your readings compare fairly. Check the results page behind every promising phrase, keep only those with real demand and buying intent, and build one thorough page for each. Measure your ceiling in Search Console as soon as data appears, then move up in steps rather than leaps. Your first pages do not need to win the biggest searches in your trade, only the ones that bring the right people to your door.
How many people search it each month, how hard it is to reach page 1 and the related searches people type, in 40 countries. No sign-up.
Check a keyword with the Keyword Difficulty Checker →